Opinion: Continuation of the anti-vaccine student mandate on a precarious legal and moral ground


Re “Student Sues San Diego Unified, Opposes Vaccination Mandate for Religious Reasons” (October 25): Junior Scripps Ranch High School known as “Jill Doe” has every right to refuse to take the COVID-19 vaccine. However, using religion as an excuse requires further consideration.

If she has ever taken acetaminophen, albuterol, Tylenol, Motrin, Benadryl, Sudafed, Claritin, Prilosec, Zoloft, or if she has been vaccinated against chickenpox and rubella, she has previously used drugs developed from fetal stem cells.

If she doesn’t want to get the shot, then she can learn from a distance and let the rest of us try to regain some semblance of normal life without the constant fear of viral exposure from uninformed individuals.

Emily liebscher
Rancho bernardo

I was disappointed with the placement of the article regarding a student suing San Diego Unified for the immunization warrant. This article made headlines which, in your opinion, indicates that it was one of the most important reports of that day in San Diego. By putting this article, which concerns the trial of a single person, on the front page, you are giving this aspect of the vaccine mandate argument great visibility.

Given the current political environment, I think it is important that the media try to moderate the discussion, not fuel the flames. By giving maximum coverage to the actions of this person, you are effectively contributing to the struggles that divide our country.

You have great power to select the articles that feature prominently in your publication; please think more about the consequences of amplifying marginal views.

Greg Vignes
Poway

Religion is no excuse to endanger others

The lawsuit brought by “Jill Doe” against the San Diego Unified vaccine mandate is the epitome of hypocrisy. If one is to believe the moral / ethical basis on which the Judeo-Christian traditions are built, namely the Ten Commandments, then it would be difficult to justify a religious exemption.

Two commandments in particular are obvious. The first is “You won’t kill,” which non-vaccines probably do. Second, “You will not lie / bear false witness,” which non-vaccines do by spreading misinformation.

I would suggest Jill stay in school and study a bit more because she, her parents, and the Thomas More Society apparently don’t know what the word pandemic means and why we need to work together as a species. to overcome this terrible situation.

Jose reynoso
College district

Opinion resources

UT welcomes and encourages community dialogue on important public issues.


Source link

Previous Rachel Held Evans' last words
Next This Enhanced Child Tax Credit Feature May Become Permanent

No Comment

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published.